Your shopping cart is empty.

Second Chance

Image of Misfit Toys for "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer TV Special," public domain)

Second Chance products deserve just that—a second chance. They may have a slight imperfection, defect, were worn previously for a photo shoot, or have been gently used. Some pieces are brand new but don’t quite fit within the updated direction we’re taking with the brand. Some are invaluable for nostalgia and childhood memories, while others simply need a fresh start. Each has a history and plenty of life left. They still deserve a loving home, and their price reflects that. Have room in your heart and home for a beloved item that has a few scuffs and imperfections—like you?

Hero Pups - Mouse - Bottles Pillows Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Hero Pups - Mouse - Bottles Pillows Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$6.00

 Condition is used   some have scuff marks & stains   Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Sale 33%
Squishmallows Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Squishmallows Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$5.99

 Condition is used   some have scuff marks & stains   Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Second Chance Disney Books second image
Select options
Second Chance Disney Books
$5.99

*Used condition* Some of these may have stickers or other flaws on them. These are sold as is, if you have any questions please ask before purchasing.

Baby Toys Rattles Second Chance Toys Variety second image
Select options
Baby Toys Rattles Second Chance Toys Variety
$4.99

USED Condition Some of these may have store price stickers still on them May have scuff marks These are sold as is If you have any questions please ask before purchasing  

Second Chance Cartoon Films Books second image
Select options
Second Chance Cartoon Films Books
$1.99

*Used condition* Some of these may have store price stickers or other flaws on them. These are sold as is, if you have any questions please ask before purchasing.

Second Chance Cartoons Huge Variety Books second image
Select options
Second Chance Cartoons Huge Variety Books
$1.99

*Used condition* Some of these may have store price stickers or other flaws on them. Notable defects on items:- All of the "Me Reader" books are missing the sound pad.  - The Wiggles "Go to Sleep, Jeff" CD has scratches, it is likely still able to be read and used. These are sold as is, if you have any questions...

Kawaii Plushie Plush Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Kawaii Plushie Plush Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$7.99

 Condition is used   some have scuff marks & stains   Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Second Chance Dolls Raggedy Ann - Cabbage Patch Kids Vintage Books second image
Select options
Second Chance Dolls Raggedy Ann - Cabbage Patch Kids Vintage Books
$5.99

*Used condition* Some of these may have store price stickers or other flaws on them. These are sold as is, if you have any questions please ask before purchasing.

Train - Buzz - Dory - Cat Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Train - Buzz - Dory - Cat Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$2.99

 Condition is used   May have stains and marks   Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Battery Powered Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Battery Powered Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$9.99

Condition is used Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Teletubbies Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Teletubbies Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$7.99

Condition is used Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Select options
Second Chance Funny Sponge Shirt
$9.99

*Used condition* Materials: 65% Polyester, 35% Cotton Measurements: Large: Length: 28” - Chest: 42”-44” - Waist: 40”-44” XL: Length: 29” - Chest: 44”-46” - Waist: 46”-48” Care Instructions: Machine wash cold with like colors. Tumble dry low. Cool iron if needed. Do not iron decoration.

Add to cart
Second Chance New Superman Underwear
$3.99

*BRAND NEW WITH TAGS* Size on Tag: Small Original Price: $10 Materials: 95% Cotton, 5% Spandex Measurements: Length: 8”-9” Hips: 26” Care Instructions: Machine wash cold with like colors. Do not bleach. Tumble dry low. Cool iron as needed.

Small Video Game Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Small Video Game Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$4.99

Condition is used   Some may have scuff marks & stains   Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Sea Critters Stuffies Second Chance Toys second image
Select options
Sea Critters Stuffies Second Chance Toys
$21.99

 Condition is used May have stains and marks   Comes from a clean and smoke free home

Load More